The science of hooking on – Building trust and the laws of learning at liberty

Picture credits: Kim Goertz

“Hooking on” in horse training is the process through which the horse chooses to be with the human, being drawn towards him and following him around without the use of a rope (I explicitly do NOT relate to a reaction that is called “join up”, which is usually performed in a round pen). In today’s blog, I would like to present this well-known paradigm in horse training as an exercise at liberty that can be explained by the laws of learning, especially through positive and negative (removal) reinforcement. Both, positive and negative reinforcements are rewarding. Thus, the hooking on technique practiced at liberty is based on rewarding this behavior on the site of the horse. 

It is therefore a training technique inducing a positive emotional state in our four-legged friends. In my Blog from June, you can find a short overview over learning theory and how the laws of learning developed ("Learning by Success" - From Thorndike's Puzzle Box to "Houdini" Horses. A short gallop through learning theory. - click here to view the blog entry

After the dead of my horse Jarpi this summer, a very nice new horse, Ljùfur, moved in. He is not mine, but also, like my Fràr, an Icelandic gelding (Ljufur is Icelandic and means “the nice one”, how true). He is about the same age as Fràr and he will stay with us through the winter. Since I have a very strong walking disability (I am a para-rider) “my” horses must accept the wheelchair. Moreover, I train and handle my horses more or less at liberty, because this is almost essential while handling horses out of the wheelchair. But of course, it cannot be expected that a horse, who has never seen a wheelchair is spontaneously perfectly relaxed with it, quite the opposite. A normal reaction would most likely be more like “….here comes this weird monster on 4 wheels which moves a bit erratically..”. So, who would trust that scary thing?

And so it was with Ljufur. He was actually very compliant, when I lead him for the first time from the paddock to the riding arena, but he was definitely not comfortable. Consequently, once he was given the chance to leave me, he would. Thus, in the riding arena, without a halter and a lead rope, he more or less turned into a hard to catch horse and made it quite clear, that I was not to trust, and that he would rather not have anything to do with that weird monster on 4 wheels. And how it is in such a situation, I did not wait for the camera, but started to work with him immediately. Because of that, I unfortunately, have no video from our first training session. However, the video from session 2 still illustrates the problem: He is not terribly afraid of the wheelchair and does not panic, but he still thinks that I am a bit scary and retreats. While he is at liberty, it is impossible for me to get into close contact with him, not talking about handling him, brushing him, or taking his hooves. He is, however, already a bit interested in me during session 2. But when it comes to it and I come closer, he would rather leave and join my horse Fràr on the other end of the riding arena.

Video 1: Ljùfur has become interested in me and comes closer. However, I am hardly allowed to touch him and when I try to get closer, he gets tense, and lifts his head. After a while of me trying to touch him, he turns around and leaves me to join my horse Fràr on the other side of the riding arena.

In session 3, we are making some progress and I am now allowed to carefully touch him. However, it is also quite obvious, that Ljùfur is not entirely comfortable with the situation and does not really enjoy being touched or scratched by the four-wheeled monster I must be to him. In this session, you can see how the technique of hooking on works. As soon, as he get’s tense, I withdraw and create

some distance between him and me. To find the right balance between approach and retreat is the key to success. My approaching him creates tension, which can be clearly seen by him raising his head and eventually stepping back. Increasing the distance to him, creates a release of that build up tension. His head goes down, and he actually becomes curious and approaches me.


In video 1 (session 2), Ljùfur reduces the tension himself, by leaving me and thus creating a distance. In video 2 (session 3), I manage to keep the balance and reduce the tension by retreating myself before he withdraws. Objects that retreat are not experienced as being scary and may even stimulate curiosity. This fact is used therapeutically to help horses overcome object anxiety and the technique is called “approach conditioning”. In the example illustrated on the Equitation Science website, a horse is afraid of tractors. In an approach conditioning paradigm, the horse is led towards the tractor, while the tractor retreats. The increase of distance releases the tension and stimulates the horses’ innate curiosity. 

Video 2: Session 3. Ljùfur becomes more interested in me and I am allowed to scratch him. He is still too tense and ambivalent to enjoy the scratches. However, when he gets tense and I withdraw, he shows curiosity and follows me. Note, that I show him objects that I intend to use when I touch him like my hands or the brush. It is important that he gets a chance to use his natural curiosity for exploration and to investigate these objects himself before he must tolerate being touched by them.

In video 1 (session 2), Ljùfur himself reduces the tension created by my closeness by moving away from me and thus creating a distance. In video 2 (session 3), I manage to maintain the "emotional balance" between approach and escape and reduce the tension by withdrawing before he withdraws. Objects that withdraw are not perceived as threatening and can even arouse curiosity. This fact is used therapeutically to help horses overcome their fear of objects. This process is known as "approach conditioning". In the example shown on the Equitation Science website, a horse is afraid of tractors. In approach conditioning, the horse is led towards the tractor while the tractor simultaneously retreats. Increasing the distance releases the tension and stimulates the horse's innate curiosity. After often only a short time, the horse is able to fully approach the previously feared object, which can then be explored by the horse, which contributes to a further reduction in fear.

Video 3: Session 4. Ljùfur’s attitude towards me has changed fundamentally

between session 3 and session 4. He enjoys scratches now and follows me

with the intent to be scratched.

Video 4:  Session 4. This video shows the episode a few minutes after video 3 within the 4th training session. After extensively scratching him, Ljùfur follows me when I start moving away from him

There was huge progress from session 3 to session 4. In session 4, Ljùfur’s attitude towards me has fundamentally changed. He now enjoys being touched and is relaxed around me. He starts following me and asks for scratches. This is interesting because this change happened overnight. While the first training sessions lasted only several minutes, session 4 was considerably longer and the following videos show only scenes of it. The first sessions were determined by him and stopped, when he left, or I observed that the tension increased instead of decreased. Session 4 was a turning point, most likely related to the fact, that he started to enjoy being scratched. Thus, I had become a resource for a positive experience, and he is showing me clearly, that he wants to be scratched and where he wants it. This development over time (different sessions) shows, that it is important to give enough time in between training sessions so that the horse has the possibility to digest the experiences and let the learning consolidate.

From that moment on, everything happened at a rapid pace. I was allowed to brush him at Liberty (video 5) and even take his hooves and scrape them out (video 6), which is frankly a very awkward procedure even for me from a wheelchair. All this happened during session 4, which lasted well over an hour.

Video 5: Session 4. Ljufur has discovered, that brushing is another form of scratches, and he now enjoys being brushed at liberty. 

Video 6: Session 4. Ljufur finds it a bit complicated to give that weird thing on wheels his hooves (I find taking the hooves out of the wheelchair also quite complicated ). However, I use a lot of scratches before I am asking for his hoof. When releasing the foot, this is in itself negative (removal) reinforcement, and I am using further scratches as additional, positive reinforcement (combined reinforcement).

Ljufùr is certainly a very nice horse, however, he was initially compliant, but not comfortable around me. Since I do not like to impose any action onto a horse, I found this exercise fundamental to develop trust and a bond between us as a basis for our further interactions. What I found interesting in his case, is that it took three sessions with approach-avoidance, which is more than I expected, while the breakthrough in session 4 was total and complete. From session 4 on, I could ask him for almost anything from the ground. His learning was only linear in the first three sessions, and then all of a sudden it accelerated dramatically between session 3 and 4. Hooking on at liberty is a well-known technique among horse trainers to connect with a horse. What I find interesting is that it can be very well explained by learning theory. 

The approach of the wheelchair is uncomfortable and increases tension, which is aversive. The release of tension by me withdrawing is the (negative/removal) reinforcement of the horse staying and thus a reward. When I can get close enough, I can positively reinforce him for staying by scratching him, which is also a reward. If the trainers’ withdrawal while hooking on, in this case me, comes too late and the horse goes away by himself, then the horse reinforces himself negatively (release of tension) for going away. This can in the worst-case lead to a hard to catch horse. The only sustainable option to fix a hard to catch horse is to reverse this learning by the hooking on technique. Nonetheless, in some cases and depending how established this behavior is, this can take quite some time.


I love science and thus learning theory. Of course, I am a psychologist 😉To me, it is so often simply amazing, how good horse trainers use applied science and learning theory in their training. Good training makes the horse feel comfortable, and that, to me, that is the most essential criterion for good training. Good horse trainers show a fundamental understanding of the horse’s nature, the way our four-legged friends think and feel, these trainers are compassionate and try to create a stress free and emotionally positive training atmosphere. Moreover, I can almost always, see how their training principles and techniques are based in learning theory, even though this fact may not play a conscious role for those good trainers in their everyday work.


For us, the “ordinary” horse lover, who want to do everything we can for our four-legged friends, who appreciate their kind nature, who would like to respect their mental abilities as well as their emotions, who aspire a bond of trust with our four-legged companions, it is not always easy to put these two perspectives, good horse training and science together. Trust your heart as well as your horse! Horses never lie <3


The following recommended readings may help.

Enjoy! Recommended readings (order according to publication year): 


Andrew M. McLean 2022. Modern Horse Training: Equitation Science Principles & Practice, Volume 1.

Eds. Nicki Stuart & Sophie Wyllie, Equitation Science International, Tuerong, Australia.


Lynn Acton 2020. What horses really want. Unlocking the secrets to trust, cooperation, and reliability.

Introducing protector leadership. Trafalgar Square Books, North Pomfret, Vermont, USA.


Paul McGreevy, Janne Winther Kristensen, Uta König von Borstel, and Andrew McLean 2018.

Equitation Science 2nd ed. John Wiley and Sons Ltd, Hoboken, United States.


For German speaking readers:

Konstanze Krüger & Isabell Marr 2022. Forschung trifft Pferd. Kosmos Verlag, Stuttgart.


Margit H. Zeitler-Feicht 2015. Handbuch Pferdeverhalten: Ursache, Therapie und Prophylaxe von Problemverhalten. Ursache, Therapie und Prophylaxe von Problemverhalten. Ulmer Verlag.