Of Horses and Humans: Are they “Healers”?

Picture credits: Kim Goertz
Photo by Inger Marie Møllnes

Having a most inspiring discussion in mind I dedicate this Blog to Bobbie Chambers Wilson.


“There is magic around horses, and they have healing powers”. I have heard it said, quite often – I have said it myself. Being chronically ill and almost completely bound to a wheelchair, I can relate to that, I feel it!


However, whenever I say or even think such a statement, that little nagging voice pops up in my head, “REALLY? Just because YOU fell in love with this expensive, unpractical, complicated, but admittedly, quite cute species does not mean, there are a miracle, not to talk about that they have healing powers.…”. There it is, that rational, sceptic, analytic scientist in me. Having almost two versions of myself, the “horse lover”, and the “scientist”, has lately accounted for most interesting inner debates and quite an inspiring journey.


While searching for answers, I usually let the scientist have her way and take it from there. So, how would she address the problem? The magic is beyond the realm of science. Scientific methods are empirical, which means, we have to have something that can be measured. I cannot see, how it would be possible to measure magic. Thus, with regard to magic, we are in the metaphysical realm, absolutely acceptable (nothing wrong with being metaphysical), but inaccessible (at least not directly) for the scientist. Nonetheless, the question as to whether horses have healing powers, that can be measured. If horses exert healing powers with regard to humans, then there should be scientific evidence that they can contribute to therapeutical interventions for persons with ill health. I use the term ill health, because I want to include all aspects of human disease, physically as well as mentally. In consequence, I would have to search for conditions and therapeutical interventions, where horses are in the role of a therapist or co-therapist.


And YESS, there is a whole world of therapeutical interventions called Equine-assisted therapy (EAT), where horses take over this role and act as a co-therapist. EAT encompasses a wide variety of interventions, from therapeutical riding to equine assisted psychotherapy (Wikipedia gives a really good overview over the topic: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Equine-assisted_therapy). Thus, horses “work” as co-therapists for the treatment of a broad spectrum of human ill health, from physical to mental health issues.


Photo by Agnete E. Kristoffersen

When running a literature search in the medical scientific databases, I was almost overwhelmed by the mere number of publications. Especially over the last 2-3 years, several “systematic reviews” have been published on a variety of EAT interventions for human ill-health. Those studies provide sound evidence that these therapies are effective. Systematic reviews are the summary across several separate clinical studies, and they are classified as the highest scientific evidence achievable. Thus, horses do an excellent job as co-therapists and scientific evidence supports that they can help persons suffering ill health to improve their lives. In this blog, I will report about some of the results, that I find particularly interesting. Thus clearly, the selection of studies and topics is biased by my own interest. Moreover, I have focused on publications that are “Open Access”, which means, that everybody who is interested can search the article through the internet, get access, and read them.


Horses have been widely used as co-therapists for the treatment of children and adolescents. In children with disabilities, hippotherapy improved spasticity (Systematic review, Hyun et al, 2022) mobility, communication, and interpersonal relationships (systematic review by Potvin-Belanger el al., 2022). In children and adolescents (age range 4-18 yrs) with autism, EAT improved social functioning most likely by reducing the stress response (systematic review by Sissons et al. 2022). In a qualitative (interview) study from Sweden in children and adolescents with mental illnesses the researchers found that EAT helped to find “relief from everyday stress and anxiety”, that the therapy was able to “nurture self-esteem in a mutual friendship” (with horses), and that EAT was able to “strengthen self-reliance through synchronized interplay” (Punzo et al., 2022). The authors stress the fact that they see EAT as essential to the value and goals of mental health nursing.


Photo by Giulia Orsatti - Equine photos

With regard to adults, EAT is often used in the treatment of neurological diseases and has been shown to improve postural control, gait speed, and balance, as well as to reduce fatigue and spasticity in patients suffering from multiple sclerosis. The patients benefitted also through improved quality of life (Systematic review by Lavín-Pérez et al., 2022). The same results on gait and movement were found investigating a population of older adults (Systematic review by Badin et al., 2022). In patients with Parkinson’s disease, EAT helped to improve their occupational performance, mood, gait and balance, as well as their quality of life (Systematic review by Berardi et al. 2022). Moreover, EAT has been shown to support persons with addictions to retain and complete their treatment, to improve their mental health, to increase self-efficacy and positive emotional affect as well as treatment motivation (Scoping review by Diaz et al. 2022). Beyond that, horses as co-therapists in combination with mindfulness self-compassion based psychotherapy were able to help Veterans who had experienced trauma. Study participants generally enjoyed the program, which is in itself an achievement as trauma and depression leads to anhedonia, which means, that a person suffering from these mental disorders finds it impossible to experience joy in activities in general. The participants felt better and less affected by the trauma, their psychological flexibility increased, and depression was reduced (clinical study by Marchand et al. 2023).


In conclusion, EAT has been shown to be beneficial for a wide variety of physical and mental disorders in adults, adolescents, and children. Thus, there is no doubt, that horses can have a major positive impact on health and disease when acting as co-therapists. Thus, yes, they have healing powers, no doubt. But WHY? What is it about horses, that gives them such power in the treatment of physical and mental human illness? With regard to physical symptoms such as balance, posture and gait, the question is easy to answer. It is probably the unique movement and balance stimulation horse riding provides, which will in turn strengthen muscles and retrain the central nervous system (yes, also including the brain). However, why do horses have such an impact on mental and emotional states? On depression, anxiety, and trauma? Is there more to them? Is there, indeed, magic around horses?


In my search, I came across a study that caught my attention way more than all the other carefully conducted studies of high quality. This one was exceptionally well conducted, but moreover, it addressed a research question of utter importance, even beyond all the good studies that I had already read. In addition, it tried to investigate the reasons, why horses were so exceptionally potent co-therapists. Laurie Haig and Kelly Skinner from the School of Public Health Sciences, University of Waterloo, Waterloo, ON, Canada investigated the “Use of Equine-Assisted Services to Improve Outcomes Among At-Risk and Indigenous Youth: A Scoping Review” (2022). Their point of departure was the notion that EAT may show “particular promise as culturally appropriate initiatives for at-risk Indigenous youth, as they are thought to align well with Indigenous ways of knowing which places emphasis on relationships between the land and all living beings”. They compiled information from studies focusing on at-risk youth aged 10-18 years of age in Canada, Australia, and the United States (a total of 27 studies). Their conclusion strongly supports that the use of EAT can support both Indigenous youth and at-risk youth in achieving their therapeutic and learning goals.

Beyond this general conclusion, what is really interesting in this scoping review is the discussion of potential mechanisms of effect as to why EAT is so effective in supporting the participants to cope with their lives. Many factors are discussed, such e.g. the mere size of the horse. Horses cannot simply be pushed around, so youth struggling with aggression had to learn how communicate with the horses, teaching them (the youth) to be assertive, without being aggressive through being totally focused on the horse. Participants, who were spontaneously approached by the horses themselves, found this experience very affirming. They interpreted these actions of the horse as an indication, that they were worthy of relationship and connection. The youth described horses as “being honest”, they felt save around horses, and experienced them as calming. They also felt that the behavior of the horses was predictable, as opposed to their experiences with unpredictable human relationships. Moreover, the participants bonded with horses in general, horses were seen as their friends, and youth felt welcome and special in the horses’ presence. Many participants formed a close bond with one particular horse, and this was experienced as very rewarding.


Another aspect of the therapeutic horse-human interaction in these studies was the phenomenon of “safe touch”. A number of participants enjoyed the physical and hands-on experience with horses and felt, that the horses provided an opportunity for safe touch. This was especially important for children and adolecents who had previous experiences of unhealthy touch and abuse. This opportunity for physical touch was also reported to help participants “to practice compassion and empathy and allowed them to feel heard, understood, and important…” (page 10, Haig & Skinner, 2022). In conclusion, EAT helped this group of youth to build confidence, self-esteem, social skills, respect, and compassion. In addition, it improved emotional regulation, reduced anger, and increased the self-awareness of feelings. And if this was not impressive enough, the participants learned to build up trusting relationships and to set and respect boundaries through their interactions with horses.


I find these studies simply amazing! Here, the horses’ role as a therapist goes way beyond a role as a co-therapist. In the compilation of studies presented by Haig & Skinner (2022) horses exerted their therapeutic effects directly through the interaction with the participants. The horses initiated and facilitated substantial changes in the youth’s emotions and behavior and consequently fostered social skills as well as personality building. I find the horses’ role as a safety signal particularly intriguing as well as fundamentally significant, both, with regard to communication, but maybe even more so, as a resource for “safe touch”.

If I look at the results of Haig & Skinner’s study, I can see that the mechanisms they describe are also of relevance for other studies investigating EAT. The therapeutic impact horses exert on humans is inseparable from the horses’ nature, their way of communicating and interacting with us, simply their way of being. Maybe that should not surprise us, horses and humans share a long common history of about 5000 years and, as I have discussed in an earlier blog, domestication is never a one-way street (https://www.scienceforhorselovers.com/en/blog-entry/of-horses-and-humans-and-how-it-all-began-the-ancient-botai-culture-of-kazakhstan). However, other animals e.g. dogs, have an even longer history of domestication and they have shown to be successful co-therapists. Yet still, horses seem to have an even larger impact when they are involved as co-therapists (e.g. Sissons et al. 2022). Why should this be so?


I don’t know for sure, but I could find some arguments why One important factor is surely that horses are very smart (https://www.scienceforhorselovers.com/en/blog-entry/little-brain-big-brain- a-little-myth-buster-discussion-about-brain-size-and-intelligence), which probably allows them to adjust to many different situations. Moreover, as herd animals, living in rather sophisticatedly organized family groups, they own a high social intelligence and are excellent communicators (even though mostly non-vocal). Thus, it may not be astounding that they can read human emotions and react accordingly (https://www.scienceforhorselovers.com/en/blog-entry/more-than-just-a-smile-horses-distinguish-between-human-happy-vs-angry-faces-and-act-accordingly). Last not least, they are capable of establishing close bonds, within their own species, as well as with humans (https://www.scienceforhorselovers.com/en/blog-entry/of-horses-and-humans-do-they-love-us). Nonetheless, let’s be careful not to step into that wide open trap of anthropomorphism: Horses have these therapeutic effects on humans exclusively because they are horses, and not humans!


Another important factor maybe the mere size of a horse (e.g. quite a big difference to dogs as therapeutic animals). The fact that they are large animals determines that humans need to find a way to communicate with them, because it is simply not possible to handle a horse, if he doesn’t want to be handled. This in itself may present a challenge, that, when overcome, may constitute a major success which is most likely experienced as very rewarding. The possibility of safe close positive physical contact with such a large animal (let’s name it, to cuddle with a mini-elephant) does something with us humans and this positive emotional experience has a defined physiological pathway (C-Fibre touch, see e.g. Musial & Weiss, 2014). In conclusion, some if not all of these therapeutic effects are fundamentally grounded in biopsychological processes, possibly most of all, the role of touch, yet also, the experience of competence, joy and trust.


Can horses be healers? Yes, they can. Is there magic around horses? As discussed before, this is a question where science is not likely to provide an answer to. Nonetheless, to me (and when it comes to it, I have two major passions in my life, horses and Biopsychology), mental, emotional, cognitive, or generally all psychological processes are inseparable from physiology/neurophysiology. I do not see these processes as fundamentally different elements of a living being, for me they are just a change of perspective, maybe for scientific purposes, but always just for a moment before they integrate again and I can see the whole picture.


Yet still, is there not also some magic around horses? At least, a little bit? Horses are successful co-therapists for humans and it seems that they can even be therapists on their own. The reason for this is grounded in the fact that there is a potential for connection between humans and horses that is based on shared emotions, mutual understanding, and the potential for a fundamental bond of trust. When I then take a step back and look at all these factors from a distant view, the perspectives melt and integrate themselves only to form one exceptional, astounding, most awesome entity, LIFE itself! And is that not the greatest and most beautiful miracle we know of?


Photo by Giulia Orsatti - Equine photos

References in alphabetical order:


https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Equine-assisted_therapy


Badin L, Alibran É, Pothier K, Bailly N. Effects of equine-assisted interventions on older adults' health: A systematic review. Int J Nurs Sci. 2022 Sep 20;9(4):542-552. doi: 10.1016/j.ijnss.2022.09.008. eCollection 2022 Oct. PMID: 36285074 Free PMC article. Review.


Berardi A, Di Napoli G, Ernesto M, Fabbrini G, Conte A, Ferrazzano G, Viselli F, Galeoto G. The Effectiveness of Equine Therapy Intervention on Activities of Daily Living, Quality of Life, Mood, Balance and Gait in Individuals with Parkinson's Disease. Healthcare (Basel). 2022 Mar 17;10(3):561. doi: 10.3390/healthcare10030561. PMID: 35327039 Free PMC article.


Diaz L, Gormley MA, Coleman A, Sepanski A, Corley H, Perez A, Litwin AH. Equine-assisted services for individuals with substance use disorders: a scoping review. Subst Abuse Treat Prev Policy. 2022 Dec 14;17(1):81. doi: 10.1186/s13011-022-00506-x. PMID: 36517823 Free PMC article. Review.


Haig L, Skinner K. Use of Equine-Assisted Services to Improve Outcomes Among At-Risk and Indigenous Youth: A Scoping Review. Front Public Health. 2022 Mar 28;10:730644. doi: 0.3389/fpubh.2022.730644. eCollection 2022. PMID: 35419329 Free PMC article.


Hyun C, Kim K, Lee S, Ko N, Lee IS, Koh SE. The Short-term Effects of Hippotherapy and Therapeutic Horseback Riding on Spasticity in Children With Cerebral Palsy: A Meta-analysis. Pediatr Phys Ther. 2022 Apr 1;34(2):172-178. doi: 10.1097/PEP.0000000000000880. PMID: 35184078 Free PMC article.


Lavín-Pérez AM, Collado-Mateo D, Caña-Pino A, Villafaina S, Parraca JA, Apolo-Arenas MD. Benefits of Equine-Assisted Therapies in People with Multiple Sclerosis: A Systematic Review. Evid Based Complement Alternat Med. 2022 Apr 27;2022:9656503. doi: 10.1155/2022/9656503. eCollection 2022. PMID: 35529929 Free PMC article. Review.


Marchand WR, Lackner R, Hartquist A, Finnell L, Nazarenko E. Evaluation of a mindfulness and selfcompassion-based psychotherapy incorporating horses for Veterans who have experienced trauma. Complement Ther Med. 2023 Jan 4;72:102914. doi: 10.1016/j.ctim.2023.102914. Online ahead of print. PMID: 36610554


Musial F, Weiss T. The healing power of touch: the specificity of the 'unspecific' effects of massage. Forsch Komplementmed. 2014;21(5):282-3. doi: 10.1159/000368449. Epub 2014 Sep 26. PMID: 25427518 No abstract available.


Naste TM, Price M, Karol J, Martin L, Murphy K, Miguel J, Spinazzola J. Equine Facilitated Therapy for Complex Trauma (EFT-CT). J Child Adolesc Trauma. 2018;11(3):289-303. doi: 10.1007/s40653- 017-0187-3. Epub 2017 Aug 17. PMID: 30220956 Free PMC article.


Potvin-Bélanger A, Vincent C, Freeman A, Flamand VH. Impact of hippotherapy on the life habits of children with disabilities: a systematic review. Disabil Rehabil. 2022 Dec;44(26):8161-8175. doi: 10.1080/09638288.2021.2012847. Epub 2022 Jan 19. PMID: 35043743 Review.


Punzo K, Skoglund M, Carlsson IM, Jormfeldt H. Experiences of an Equine-Assisted Therapy Intervention among Children and Adolescents with Mental Illness in Sweden - A Nursing Perspective. Issues Ment Health Nurs. 2022 Dec;43(12):1080-1092. doi: 10.1080/01612840.2022.2126571. Epub 2022 Sep 30. PMID: 36178465


Sissons JH, Blakemore E, Shafi H, Skotny N, Lloyd DM. Calm with horses? A systematic review of animal-assisted interventions for improving social functioning in children with autism. Autism. 2022 Aug;26(6):1320-1340. doi: 10.1177/13623613221085338. Epub 2022 Apr 11. PMID: 35403450 Free PMC article.