This one goes out to Marianne & Diogo and all the hardworking, dedicated, and bravehearted veterinarians out there, helping us, to do the best we can for our four-legged companions. May the kindness of their hearts never wane, and their spirit be unbreakable!
It has been a bit quiet from me lately, I have lost a horse, my beloved Jarpi. I am certainly not the only one who has ever lost a horse, I know, this is not the first time it happened. It is something we all fear and try to prepare ourselves for it. Nonetheless, even though, I was sort of prepared that it will happen one day, grief and sorrow overwhelmed me like I would have never thought possible. So, let’s start with the conclusion: there is no good way to say goodbye. And there is no science here to help…
It’s been a strange summer, even before it hit Jarpi, I had friends losing a horse this summer. I felt so sorry for them, I felt empathic and thought how terrible it must be to lose such a beloved friend. Little did I know what it really meant!
Not long after it happened to me, Tania Kindersley the author of the Blog “The Red Mare” wrote about it ( https://www.facebook.com/photo/?fbid=667619592069530&set=a.395979419233550 ). She wrote many things I can relate to, and this is a wonderful blog from somebody who knows what this is about. However, the one thing she wrote that keeps coming up in my mind, the thought, that does not leave me and at the same time gives some consolation is this “…Don’t let anyone tell you it was ‘only a horse’. Love is love. Your heart is broken. ...”
It took me a long time to finally find the strength to sit down and write this blog. With grief and sorrow came a mental lameness that I had not experienced before. I had decided to write about my loss, hoping, it could be a kind of therapy for me, that it would help to structure my thoughts and feelings, and that it would, in the end and hopefully, help me to deal with the mourning.
Beyond that, I also thought, that sharing my experience, the sorrow, and the grief, may maybe not help, but show others, that they are not alone. As Tanias Kindersley’s Blog helped me… There is no shame in being heartbroken by the loss of a beloved companion.
I guess, there are many possible ways to lose a horse. Horses are more fragile than you would ever imagine of such a large animal. They can very suddenly become ill, like in case of a colic, they can injure themselves, they can break a leg, they can develop a sudden burst of laminitis, it is astounding how fast they can become very, very, and terminally ill. We want to help them, we care for them, we do not want them to suffer. In those cases of acute suffering, the last resort when there is no perspective for healing, not even talking about surviving, the most “humane” thing to do is to take their live in the kindest way possible.

Photo by Agnete E. Kristoffersen

Photo by Giulia Orsatti
And then, there is this situation, where there was, at least at some point a perspective for healing, but you realize, that this cannot be achieved, and the suffering does not justify the outcome anymore. And because you love your horse, you decide to put an end to his ordeal. Still, you must decide on the day, you must call the vet, you have to prepare for it. You may need some time, to come to terms with this decision, you may wait a bit longer, maybe you are not sure that this is the right thing to do, but in the end, you do it. But afterwards, there may be constant doubt, if this really was the right decision, maybe you could have done something else, maybe there still was a chance for healing and you gave up too early? It will take time, maybe forever, to get over this doubt.
I will tell you the story of Jarpi, even if the diagnosis is not pretty (which one is). Equestrians can deal with a lot; they have seen many things and they are usually prepared for almost everything. We which means my horses went to the summer pasture by the end of June, which is common here in Northern Norway. The time they can be out in the fields is pretty much limited to July, August, and maybe September and during this time, almost all stables are empty because the horses move to other places for the pasture season.
My two horses, geldings, have a tradition to spend the summer with an old friend of them at my friend Virve’s place. Summer can be beautiful up here in the North and there is nothing more soulful than seeing these three meet again, greet and “hug” each other, and then either playing for a while or drifting away into the field with the grass up to their bellies. They celebrate the summer and their short-lasting freedom as mindful as we humans never could. Every time I see them drifting away in perfect bliss, I hear “sunshine reggae” from LaidBack playing somewhere in the back of my mind. Every year, at the day of the move, summer season opens, and we all together, two-legged and fourlegged, are happy go lucky and ready for endless carefree, blissful and lighthearted summer days and nights (midnight sun!).
One day, my friend discovered dark nods at the end of Jarpi’s penis. It might have been clotted blood, and it definitely did not look good. He did have some small red spots on his penis that where regularly checked. But they had not changed in at least 9 months, so I was not particularly concerned. When the veterinarian came and investigated him, a nightmare was confirmed: he had developed a squamous cell carcinoma. The plaques were still mostly flat, and he did not seem to be bothered by it, we had not seen any change in his behavior, but there were many of them. The whole penis was covered, it was an ugly view.
It came as a total shock, he seemed to be in perfect shape, happy and healthy as he could possibly be. Nonetheless, he was a Pinto, and they are especially exposed where their skin is light. He was 15 years old, which is where the incidence is increasing. Squamous cell carcinoma can be very aggressive and apparently this one was, because it had developed from a few almost not visible red dots to this catastrophe in only three months.
For the rest of my life, I will be deeply grateful to my friend Virve and her family, as well as to the two veterinarians involved. I do not know what I would have done without them. We discussed the therapeutic options which were penis-amputation with a reconstruction of the urinary tract or a trial with local chemotherapy. Surgery was never an option; I would have never done that to him. He does not know about a “perspective” of being healthy again (if that would ever have been so, because we did not know, whether he had developed metastases). In his world, he would have been kidnapped to a place not known to him, tortured, and then he would wake up to a body, that was completely distorted and different than before. There was no way, I would have done this to him. I did considered the other option, local chemotherapy. It is apparently a treatment that can work in early stages. However, the cancer had quite progressed, and it would have been a large area to treat. It hurts, because it “burns” the cancer away. He would have to be treated every day and the pain would continue for months after the treatment ended. Not talking about having to sedate him every day during treatment. And then, there was still the question of metastases.
I was tempted, I was desperately clinging to the chance of healing and thus every possible treatment that would give me the little funny, cuddly, happy go lucky horse back, that I loved so much! So, I almost decided to try chemo. But then, I tried to imagine how this would have been for him. Horses cannot anticipate the future; he would never understand that this ordeal was for a “greater good”. In his world, he would be tortured every day by the humans he once trusted and he would not understand why this was so. And even with pain medication, he would be in pain for many months and would not understand why.
I have sworn to each of my horses to protect them from harm, never let them down, and never leave them. So, what was the idea of treatment? To avoid the inevitable, pain and suffering that would come, if the plaques grew out to tumors. In the end, he would be in severe, unimaginable pain, not able to urinate, and it would happen fast. I would never let that happen.
After many discussions with the veterinarian, with my friend Virve, with my husband, with other friends, who are so much more experienced than me, I decided against chemotherapy. I came to the conclusion, that even after a successful treatment that in itself included a tremendous amount of suffering, he would not be the happy little horse anymore, that he was and that I loved so much. After being through this ordeal, he would be a different horse, for the sake of a prognosis that was still not good, and he would not understand.

Photo by Agnete Kristoffersen
Yes, it was the hardest thing to do, to take the life of a horse, that was as happy as he could be. But I also knew that time was running out. I do not know; how much time could have been left for him to be symptom free. And I actually believe that he must have had symptoms already by the time, the vet came, and we found out that the cancer had finally come and exploded. According to the vet, it was possibly even less than four weeks before he would have severe symptoms and dysfunctions at this stage.
We decided to euthanize him at about a week after the diagnosis, which gave us some time to prepare. It is not easy to euthanize a horse on private property which is not a farm. What do you do with the body? How do we do this with regard the other horses? Where do we do this, so not all neighbors have to suffer the view of a dead horse lying around. So many practical challenges, so many things to organize. I am so deeply thankful, we were not sent away, that we were able to have him sleep in, where he was as happy as he could be, where he was among his best friends, and where he felt safe.
We made a plan and prepared him and the other horses for the procedure. It had to happen a little distance away from the other horses, because his dead body had to lie for a while at a place, where the truck which was supposed to collect him, would have access. Every day, we went for a little walk with all three and when we came back, they all got a handful of their favorite condensed feed. He received his bucket at a little distance from the others in the place, where we were planning to have it done. Thus, this procedure was as normal as it could be after a few days.
These last days were terrible, I was heartbroken, and my friends were too. I felt like I was doing the worst betrayal of his trust that I could possibly do, to take his life while he was trusting me so much. It was a different veterinarian who would perform the procedure. I know both vets well and they are wonderful veterinarians. How blessed we were, that it was these two to be involved. We discussed every detail and I guess; all was prepared as good as it could possibly be. We performed the routine that we had established during the week before. We went for a walk, came back, and he was happy and perfectly trustful towards me when he was enjoying his bucket of his most favorite feed. During eating, he was sedated and when he slept, the other horses were led away to a place, where they could not see what happened. I don’t think he felt the prick of the sedation very much, he did not show a reaction to it. When he slept unconsciously in my arms, yet still on his legs, the vet asked me to leave as we had discussed before. This is necessary, because horses can exhibit violent automated movements in the final phase in deep unconsciousness, and I am sitting in a wheelchair. So, I left.

Photo by Carley Quinn
When everything was over, we let the other horses see him, touch him and spending some time with their dead friend and companion. It was heartbreaking, they understood immediately. They touched him, they touched his muzzle, and then they knew he had gone forever. I believe they were mourning; they were withdrawn for weeks. I am not sure how much they suffer, death maybe more natural for them than it is for us. Yet, I am sure we did the right thing to show them their dead friend.
I have seen other horses losing their companions who did not have the chance to understand, that they will never come back. These horses were calling out and searching for their companions for a long time, maybe forever? Who knows. Our two remaining horses appear to be different now compared to before. They are closer to each other, and it seems, that they also show more affiliative behavior towards us. There is no way to protect them from the loss of their friend and we humans cannot understand, what this means to them. They are herd animals, and they can develop strong bonds among each other. I still feel that this was the right thing to do, to let them, in a way, participate and give them a chance to understand and to deal with the loss in their own way. I would do it like this again when it came to it.
The grief and the sorrow before Jarpi died and while preparing his dead, felt already close to unbearable, yet I was still focusing on all the practical necessities, that were to be organized. It did not prepare me for the sorrow and the mourning that overwhelmed me afterwards. Moreover, I felt that I had betrayed him, that I had let him down, that I broke my promise. He trusted me and I walked him right to his death.
However, I did see something in these final minutes, that confirms what everybody, especially the veterinarian said, it was the right decision. Not a nice memory, yet I am in fact thankful to have seen it. I saw a tumor about the size of a blackberry that had already grown out during these few days from the diagnoses to the day he left us. There were possibly 20 or so more plaques so it is easy to imagine, what would have happened in the weeks to come.
My mind tells me it was the right and the kindest thing to do for him, but my heart tells me otherwise. I still get spells of sadness and guilt where I have an inner debate if I could have done more to save his life. And while writing this, the tears still run but I keep writing. It is good to structure my thoughts and will help in the months and years to come, to reflect on what happened.
Beyond all the grief and sorrow, I am so deeply grateful for all the human friends around me. Virve, who did not send us away to a slaughterhouse, but from the first terrible moment stood with us, so Jarpi could sleep in among his friends, on a bright sunny day, surrounded by the people who love him. The vet, who made the diagnoses and endless phone calls, checked every possible option, and never got tired to answer my questions. And when it came to the insight, that there was nothing to do and that it was best to let him go while he was still not suffering, she made it very clear that she thought this was the right decision and that there was no time to lose. Her competence as well as her trust in me helped enormously.
I am so blessed to have friends that I could call or message, with all my questions on how to do it best, for him, but likewise for the other horses. That I could lean on afterwards, with all my doubts and sorrow. And every single one of them said something that eased my pain and helped me to live on. One of them said something, that I had not thought about before: That we should look at it as a privilege that we humans can do this for them and that she wished, somebody would do this for her when it comes to it. That thought helped my troubled mind, yes, it is a privilege, and we should be grateful for it!
It had to be another vet who euthanized Jarpi, however, he is also one of our vets that I have known for a long time. The way he prepared me for this and supported me during this procedure, his empathy and kindness were outstanding, and it made the inevitable manageable for me. He found beautiful words of consolation, that eased my mind and touched my wounded heart. He also said something wise, that might be helpful for all of us who have been there themselves or will face this situation one day: “Please remember, the depth of your grief reflects the strength of your love for Jarpi”.
Yes, it is as Tania Kindersley wrote “Love is love” and I did love this horse, and I still do. He was a member of a family and a band of friends, no matter whether they have four or two legs, and he is desperately missed.
Slowly, after weeks and weeks of almost not being able to think about anything else than these last days and minutes with him, other thoughts emerge, and I have started to look at old pictures of him. There is still so much pain and sorrow over the loss, but I have started to remember the clever, funny, and cuddly little horse he was. When he came into my life, I already had a horse that I was very attached to and I was worried, whether I would manage to care for both in the same way. At that time, I had a dear colleague of Sami heritage (Sami: The indigenous people of Fennoscandinavia), and she said something wise that turned out to be very true: “You will see, they will both find their place in your heart. It will be a different one, yet deep in your heart”.

Photo by Carley Quinn
I am not sure I am through the worst, but I have started to think about all the good times we had. The trembling ground, when both suddenly burst out in wild play in the paddock or on the track. The day they “stole” my beanie to play with it, at minus 10 degree Celsius, because the track was too icy to run but they needed something to play with. When they slept in my presence, on a sunny and warm spring day, when he, Jarpi, used to come up to me “kissing” me with his nostrils right up in my face and cuddling back when he was scratched or brushed. The day on the summer pasture, when he was lying down, and I was visiting him with my cross-country scooter. He did not want to get up, instead he was trying to get me down and when I did, he snuggled his head against my chest and did not let me go. I am deeply grateful to have had him in my life, for the things I have learned from him, and for these most precious moments of peace and deep connection to another soul.
He, the vet walking by our side on this final, sad and mournful journey said another wise thing to me ”…In time, I hope the good memories provide you comfort, and the pain of his absence is replaced by the joy of having been part of his life”. He may be right

